Stingy Investor Contact - Subscribe - Login
  Home | Articles | Screens | Links | SNW | Rothery Report
 
Graham Stocks in Short Supply

Over the past three years, I've used Benjamin Graham's time-tested strategy for defensive investors to uncover undervalued stocks. So far, the results have been extraordinary with significant gains each year.

Benjamin Graham first outlined his rules for defensive investors in The Intelligent Investor which has been in bookstores for more than fifty years. For those new to Graham, an updated edition of The Intelligent Investor (ISBN 0060555661) was released this summer with a forward by noted financial journalist Jason Zweig. Despite Zweig's sterling prose, the intelligent book buyer should consider picking up an inexpensive used copy.

Graham's rules for defensive investors are briefly summarized in Figure 1. Each year only a few stocks meet Graham's stringent rules for earnings growth at a low price and his method often rejects all stocks as unsuitable. Rejection has certainly been the rule in recent times and the situation is even worse this year.

Figure 1: Benjamin Graham's Criteria for the Defensive Investor
P/E Ratio less than 15.
P/Book Ratio less than 1.5.
Book Value over 0.
Current Ratio over 2.
Earnings growth of 33% over 10 years.
Uninterrupted dividends over 20 years.
Some earnings in each of the past 10 years.
Annual revenue of more than $100 Million (1950).
Source: The Intelligent Investor, 4th Revised Edition (pages 184-185).


To implement Graham's rules I use the MSN.com stock screener which does a reasonably good job; but the screener doesn't have the wealth of historical data needed to fully implement Graham's rules. For instance, the MSN.com database only contains five years of data on each stock and, as a result, I trimmed down Graham's rules to those shown in Figure 2. Even with these relaxed rules, only nine stocks passed all tests in 2000, five in 2001, and ten in 2002. Regrettably, only two stocks passed the test this year. To put this in perspective, there are currently over 6,600 stocks in the MSN.com database.

Figure 2: Screening criteria used to approximate Graham's rules
P/E Ratio less than 15.
P/Book Ratio less than 1.5.
Book Value more than 0.01.
Current Ratio more than 2.
Annual EPS Growth (5 Yr Avg) more than 2.9186%.
5 Year Dividend Growth more than 0%.
5 Year P/E Low more than 0.01.
1 Year Revenue more than $400 Million.


The nine picks of 2000 continue to do well with seven stocks gaining ground and only two losing. A stock by stock breakdown is shown in Table 1 with the average gain for these stocks a very healthy 107.3%. Given that the S&P500 fell by 22.2% over the same period, the Graham stocks managed a remarkable outperformance of 129.5 percentage points over three years. I should hasten to add, that outperforming the index by such a large margin should in no way be considered typical, or even expected.

Table 1: Performance of previous Graham Picks (October 3 2003)
StockInitial Price Current PriceGain
2000 Graham Stocks (12/12/2000)
AAR Corp (AIR) $11.94 $9.70 -15.8%
Haverty Furniture (HVT) $10.06 $20.76 112.4%
La-z-boy (LZB) $15.88 $23.20 52.7%
Rollins Truck (RLC) Bought in 2001 82.0%
Reliance Steel (RS) $25.13 $23.00 -5.9%
Tredegar Corp (TG) $15.56 $15.70 3.5%
Thor Industries (THO) $19.69 $60.70 *517.7%
Wabash National (WNC) $7.81 $16.75 116.1%
Watsco (WSO) $11.35 $19.65 102.6%
Average Gain107.3%
S&P500 (SPY)-22.2%
2001 Graham Stocks (10/29/2001)
Centex (CTX) $39.45 $83.71 112.8%
Domtar (DTC) $8.19 $11.38 43.0%
Haverty Furniture (HVT) $12.80 $20.76 65.3%
M.D.C. Holdings (MDC) $27.35 $59.11 *164.1%
Pulte Homes (PHM) $33.83 $71.42 111.8%
Average Gain99.4%
S&P500 (SPY)-1.4%
2002 Graham Stocks (10/27/2002)
Centex (CTX) $43.38 $83.71 93.3%
Pulte Homes (PHM) $46.17 $71.42 55.0%
D.R. Horton (DHI) $20.16 $36.12 80.4%
Woodward Governor Company (WGOV) $36.62 $45.97 28.1%
M.D.C. Holdings (MDC) $37.91 $59.11 *72.5%
Standard Pacific (SPF) $25.10 $40.39 62.2%
Seaboard (SEB) $207.00 $229.50 12.3%
Universal Forest Products (UFPI) $18.34 $26.93 47.3%
Haverty Furniture (HVT) $11.75 $20.76 78.7%
Watsco, Inc. (WSO) $14.25 $19.65 38.7%
Average Gain56.8%
S&P500 (SPY)16.3%
Source: quote.yahoo.com, *Adjusted for splits


It turns out that the five picks of 2001 also boasted extraordinary performance with an average gain of 99.4%. Table 1 shows that the worst individual performer gained over 42% and the best 164%. The S&P500, on the other hand, fell 1.4% over the same period, which translates into superior outperformance of 100.8 percentage points for the 2001 Graham picks.

Last year's picks were also strong performers with an average gain of 55.8%. Table 1 shows that individual stocks gained between 12.3% and 93.3%. The S&P500 trailed the Graham stocks by 40.5 percentage points and gained only 16.3% over the same period.

Clearly Graham's defensive approach has done quite well but such results are unlikely to continue. It has been my experience that periods of significant outperformance are usually followed by periods of severe underperformance. Be warned that buying into a style that has recently done well is no guarantee that it will continue to do well.

This year's crop of Graham stocks is shown in Table 2. Since stocks tend to move very rapidly, I suggest checking the MSN.com screener to be sure that the stocks in Table 2 continue to fit Graham's criteria.

Table 2: U.S. listed stocks that pass Graham's tests as of the close of 10/03/03 from www.msn.com
CompanyPrice ($)P/EP/E 5Yr LowP/Book5Yr EPS Growth (%)Current RatioDebt To Equity1Yr Revenue (M)5Yr Dividend Growth (%)
Pulte Homes (PHM) 71.42 8.8 3.4 1.48 280.9 2.7 0.76 7918 7.5
Ameron Int. (AMN) 33.85 9.5 4.9 1.14 49.3 2.5 0.43 576 1.1


It is important to note that stock screeners can be deceptive at times because they aren't always up to date. For example, if a company suffers from a sudden calamity then the stock may continue to be highlighted as good pick based on old data. One often finds stocks that look good in a stock screener but aren't good for a portfolio. I usually like to see some indication that a company's situation has remained largely unchanged before buying. For instance, looking at recent news stories on the company often helps.

This year the pickings are slim with only two Graham stocks. Naturally, investing in only two stocks is not recommended. Furthermore, deep value picks can be psychologically difficult for many investors. So, if you are considering stocks, remember Warren Buffett's admonition that "Unless you can watch your stock holding decline by 50% without becoming panic-stricken, you should not be in the stock market."

Additional Resources:

First published in the November 2003 edition of the Canadian MoneySaver magazine.

  MoneySense Articles
 Cdn Top 200 2016
 US Top 500 2016
 Retirement 100: 2015
 Cdn Top 200 2015
 US Top 500 2015
 Retirement 100: 2014
 Cdn Top 200 2014
 US Top 500 2014
 Retirement 100: 2013
 Cdn Top 200 2013
 US Top 500 2013
 Retirement 100: 2012
 Buffett Buys
 FB IPO
 Stocks that pay
 Value in the S&P500
 Cdn Top 200 2012
 US Top 500 2012
 Retirement 100: 2011
 Where to invest $100k
 Where to invest $10k
 Summer Simple Way
 A crystal ball for stocks?
 Cheap & safe
 Risky business
 Cdn Top 200 2011
 US Top 500 2011
 Retirement 100
 Dividend investing
 Value investing
 Momentum investing
 Low P/E P/B
 Dividends
 Dividend growers
 Cdn Top 200 2010
 US Top 500 2010
 Graham's prescription
 Income 100: 2009
 The case for optimism
 Cdn Top 200 2009
 U.S. Top 500 2009
 Wicked investments
 Simply spectacular
 Income 2008
 Small stocks, big profits
 Cdn Top 200 2008
 US Top 500 2008
 Value that sizzles
 So simple it works
 Income 100
 No assembly required
 Investing by the book
 Cdn Top 200 2007
 US Top 500 2007
 Invest like the masters
 A simple way to get rich
 Top Trusts 2006
 Stocks for cannibals
 Car bites dogs
 Cdn Top 200 2006
 US Top 1000 2006
 So easy, so profitable
 Top Trusts 2005
 Dogs of the Dow
 Top 200 2005
 Money for nothing
 Yield of dreams
 Return of the master

MoneySaver Articles
 2 Graham Stocks for 2017
 3 Stingy Stocks for 2016
 5 Graham Stocks for 2016
 3 Stingy Stocks for 2015
 3 Graham Stocks for 2015
 3 Stingy Stocks for 2014
 4 Graham Stocks for 2014
 8 Stingy Stocks for 2013
 6 Graham Stocks for 2013
 9 Stingy Stocks for 2012
 8 Graham Stocks for 2012
 Simple Way 2011
 5 Stingy Stocks for 2011
 7 Graham Stocks for 2011
 Simple Way 2010
 5 Stingy Stocks for 2010
 8 Graham Stocks for 2010
 Simple Way 2009
 Timing Temptation
 19 Stingy Stocks for 2009
 4 Graham Stocks for 2009
 Simple Way 2008
 Active at Passive Prices
 Unbundling ETFs 2008
 5 Stingy Stocks for 2008
 5 Graham Stocks for 2008
 Is your index too active?
 Graham's Simple Way
 Canadian Graham Stocks
 5 Stingy Stocks for 2007
 8 Graham Stocks for 2007
 Top SPPs
 The Simple Way
 A hole in your IPO?
 Monkey Business
 8 Stingy Stocks for 2006
 Graham Stock Gainers
 Blue-Chip Blues
 Are Dividends Safe?
 SPPs for 2005
 Graham's Simplest Way
 Selling Graham Stocks
 RRSP Money Market Funds
 Stingy Stocks for 2005
 High Performance Graham
 Intelligent Indexing
 Unbundling Canadian ETFs
 A history of yield
 A Dynamic Duo
 Canadian Graham Stock
 Dividends at Risk
 Thrifty Value Stocks
 Stocks in Short Supply
 The New Dividend
 Hunting Goodwill
 SPPs for 2003
 RRSP: don't panic
 Desirable Dividends
 Stingy Selections 2003
 10 Graham Picks
 Growth Eh?
 Timing Disaster
 Dangerous Diversification
 The Coffee Can Portfolio
 Down with the dogs
 Stingy Selections
 Frugal Funds
 Graham Revisited
 Just Spend It
 Ticker Temptation
 Stock Mortality
 Focus on Fees
 SPPs for the Long Term
 Seeking Solid Stocks
 Relative Strength
 The VR Approach
 The Irrational Investor
 Value Investing

Globe & Mail Articles
 Indexing advice
 Media-shy stocks
 Curse of size
 Market uncertainty
 Be even lazier
 Scary beats safe
 Small, illiquid, value
 Use the numbers
 What value is good value?
 Sculpt for value
 Value vs CAPE
 Graham Rules
 CAPE vs PeakE
 Top value ratio
 Low Beta
 Value and dividends
 Walter Schloss
 Try unloved AIG
 Why I'm a value investor
 New world of ETFs
 Low P/Es possible
 10 yielders
 Be happier
 Long-Short
 Dividend Downside
 Shiller's P/E
 Copycat investing
 Cashing in on class
 Index roulette
 Theory collides
 Diving too deep
 3 retirement villains
 Scourge of inflation
 Economic omens
 Analyst Expectations
 Value stock scarcity
 It's all in the index
 How to pick good funds
 Low Beta Wins
 Hunt for dividend stocks
 Think garage sale

Advisor's Edge Articles
 Passive Rebundling
 Doing the math

Norm Speaks
Flip Books

Tools:
 Asset Mixer
 Periodic Table
 ETF Fee Calculator



 
About Us | Legal | Contact Us
Disclaimers: Consult with a qualified investment adviser before trading. Past performance is a poor indicator of future performance. The information on this site, and in its related newsletters, is not intended to be, nor does it constitute, financial advice or recommendations. The information on this site is in no way guaranteed for completeness, accuracy or in any other way. More...